Mackinaw River Valley Civil War Civilian

Regimental Sutler Impression

Home
Origins and Mission
Research
Events Calendar
Impressions
Photo Albums
Engaging a Speaker
Related Links
Author's Credentials
Nine Months To Shiloh
Leave A Message
Sources
----------

Mary Tippee, Sutler, 114th Pennsylvania
marytippeefemalesutler114thpenncomp.jpg
CivilWarPhotos.Net

Sutler's Tent, Petersburg, Virginia
sutlerstentpetersburgvacomp.jpg
Library of Congress

The sutler was an integral part of every Union regiment. The man, or in one case woman, who filled the post of sutler was approved and appointed by the army. The appointment was supposed to be independent and impartial, but in reality many sutlers received politically motivated appointments. There was a lot of profit to be made during the war, and a host of men, both civilian and military, who aimed to share in that profit.

 

Sutlers Row, Chattanooga, Tennessee
sutlersrowchattanoogatncomp.jpg
CivilWarPhotos.Net

 

Each regiment had but one sutler, and the soldiers of the regiment were required to purchase from that person only. The sutler, too, was supposed to sell only to the soldiers in his regiment. Again, this was difficult to police, even if the officers did care enough to try to enforce this particular order. Since soldiers of different regiments shared friendships and family ties, it is not difficult to understand that they would also share provisions purchased from their sutlers.

 

Sutler's Tent, Rappahannoc Station, Virginia
sutlerstentrappahannocstationcomp.jpg
Library of Congress

Often the sutler was the most despised man in camp. Because he was a civilian and a man of commerce, his motives for being in camp were different than the 1000 men he was supposed to serve. He was there to sell at a profit, and businessmen generally try to maximize their profits. Since the sutler had a monopoly on camp business, he often attempted to sell inferior goods at inflated prices. This practice was so common that when the soldiers became infuriated to the point of revenge, after they raided the sutler's tents and stole what they wanted from him, the regiment's officers rarely intervened. They, too, believed the sutler had it coming.

Sutler's Bomb Proof, Petersburg, Virginia
sutlersbombproofpetersburgvacomp.jpg
Library of Congress

 

 

When pay day came, sutlers were in line before any of the soldiers so they could present their receipts and be paid what the soldiers owed them on credit. There was a limit to how much sutlers could loan a soldier, and if their receipts ran over the limit, they lost out. The army would not pay the excess. When the soldiers received their pay, the loan that was paid to the sutler was deducted from what they received.

 

 

Sutlers Tent, Brandy Station, Virginia
sutlerstentbrandystationvacomp.jpg
Library of Congress

 

 

Sutlers were strictly forbidden from selling the soldiers alcohol. Consequently, ingenious means of hiding strong drink from the officers was found. Liquor was hidden in pies, in cans labeled milk or fruit, or any other innocent appearing device the sutlers could devise. Sutlers were, however, permitted to sell alcohol to officers. The restriction was that any alcohol transported to a sutler had to be delivered to the officers within 24 hours, or it would be confiscated by those officers.

Rock Island, Illinois, Prison Sutler with Officers
rockislandprisonsutlercomp.jpg
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers

 

 

 

The way commercial sutlers at reenactments set up their tents and sell their wares does not recreate the Civil War sutler's arrangement. A soldier would never be allowed in a sutler's tent. Why? Because the sutler could not trust the soldiers. They loathed him and he paid the consequences with mistrust and the need for increased security.

 

Sutlers Tent, Bealeton, Virginia
sutlerstentbealetonvacomp.jpg
Library of Congress

 

 

A sutler always set up a sales counter across his entrance. Whatever the soldier wanted to purchase, he asked for it at the counter and the sutler retrieved it. This is the setup used for the Mackinaw River Valley impression. No photographs are available at this time, but the photos here represent how the impression looks.

 

Newspaper Vendor in Union Camp in Virginia
vanewspapervendorincampcomp.jpg
Library of Congress

 
Sources that Contributed to the Creation of the Sutler Impression
 
Barber, Lucius W., 1839-1872. Army Memoirs of Lucius W. Barber, Company "D," 15th Illinois Volunteer Infantry : May 24, 1861, to Sept. 30, 1865. Alexandria, Virginia: Time-Life Books, 1984, c1981. Reprint. Originally published: Chicago: J.M.W. Jones Stationery and Print. Co., 1894.
 
Cunningham, Michael R. Follow Me To Victory or Death: The Diaries and Letter of Captian Henry Martin Kellog, 33rd Illinois Volunteer Infantry. Louisville, Kentucky: University of Louisville, 1993.
 
Depasquale, Stephen M. The Twentieth Illinois Infantry Regiment. Normal, Illinois: Master’s Thesis, Department of History, 1993.
 
Geer, Allen Morgan, 1840-1926. The Civil War Diary of Allen Morgan Geer, Twentieth Regiment, Illinois Volunteers. Denver: R. C. Appleman, c1977.
 
Iseminger, Tubal Wile. Civil War Diaries and Letters of Tubal Wile Iseminger, 1862-1865. Collinsville, Illinois:  William Robert Iseminger, 1988.
 
Jessee, James W. Alan D. Selig, Transcriber. William P. LaBounty, Editor. Civil War Diaries of James W. Jessee 1861-1865. Normal, Illinois: McLean County Genealogical Society, 1997.
 
Peters, George A. Diary of “G. Peters, High Private. North Little Rock, Arkansas: Family Time Books, 1998.
 
Stillwell, Leander. The Story of a Common Soldier. Franklin Hudson Publishing Company, 1920. Reprinted in 1983. Place of publication not revealed.
 
Wiley, Bell Irvin. The Life of Billy Yank: The Common Soldier of the Union. Garden City, New York: Doubleday and Company, Inc., 1952, 1971.

This site was created in October, 2004.  All original material is copyrighted and any blame or credit should be attributed to the owner and operator, Van O. Furrh.